Saturday, September 20, 2014
"Ustad Ali Akbar Khan: The Jodhpur Years" -- A Hidden Gem of a Book and my rambling account of reading it...
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
MIXED TAPE - a chance find

That is Trilok Gurtu in full flow…he appears on the cover of a real gem of a book … MIXED TAPE – the First City Interviews 3: Music … you can call it luck or chance or more profound names as karma or serendipity … or whatever … if I hadn’t visited the bookstall at Hyderabad airport, I wouldn’t have known about this book at all … and I am sure, I wouldn’t have been able to find this book at any book stall in Hyderabad … it is not an old book published years back, but one which came out sometime this year… I was actually putting together a pile of books that I wanted to read, planning to buy at least a couple, and I was looking behind the books kept in the foreground on all the stacks in the shelves…and I saw this book…the word ‘music’ held me…I pulled it out and as it happened many times before with books on music, I forgot all about the other books that I was piling up…
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
A much awaited book...and a small, but impactful, publishing house
I have been watching out for the publication of this particular book about Hindustani classical music for a long long time…when I saw the reference of this book for the first time, sometime in 2000 or so, it was in the catalogue of the publisher, I thought I must have this book…at that time, I was totally ‘into’ music…reading about and listening to ‘fusion’ and Hindustani classical music…so much so that my actual research got derailed for some time…anyway, it said ‘forthcoming’ under a brief description of the book and a tentative list of topics…I wrote to the publisher and it was still ‘forthcoming’… I wrote after six months or so and it was still ‘forthcoming’…I had seen another book in the catalogue and decided to buy that…it was Ustad Alladiya Khan’s ‘autobiography,’ called ‘My Life.’… Ustad Alladiya Khan is the founder of the Jaipur-Atrauli Gharana, and his autobiography, dictated to his grandson towards the end of his illustrious life, is a fascinating moving picture of Hindustani classical music from the mid nineteenth century to almost the mid twentieth centuries … though I was vaguely aware of a bygone Hindustani classical world – the world of small principalities, their court singers, royal patronage, musical one-upmanship, singers and their families, bandishes being closely guarded like family treasures, etc. – Ustad Alladiya Khan’s book revealed this world in full colour…not through photographs, but through words…this is still a cherished book in my musical library…
Thema is a small publishing venture in Calcutta and publishes books in both English and Bengali…and it has got a compact and ‘impact’ful list of books in its various subsections…women’s studies, oral history, Indian history, children’s literature, culture studies, film studies, radical literature, science…
I browsed the site and saw two more books that interested me… I then spoke to them and placed an order for these three books…the books arrived yesterday…
Ok…the much awaited book is ‘Music and Modernity: North Indian Classical Music in An Age of Mechanical Reproduction’ (edited by Amlan Dasgupta) … what first struck me was the subtitle…a reference to the famous essay by Walter Benjamin…The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction…the articles in this book range from early gramophone records to the forms of the Sarod and from women musicians to reflections on the Khayal…some articles do look tough…but that is challenge…
The other two books that I bought are Imaginary Maps, a book of short stories by Mahasweta Devi (Translated by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak) and Manik Bandyopadhyay: Selected Stories (Edited and introduced by Malini Bhattacharya)… there are more that I want to read from Thema…one by one…
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Ustad Amir Khan...memories by Pt Amarnath...A Book...

A few posts earlier I had written about my fascination and admiration for Ustad Amir Khan’s singing…I think one has to hear him singing once to realise the difference between his style and the others’…it is said that most of the singers who came after him, irrespective of Gharana, imbibed a number of features of his singing…Pt Bhimsen Joshi has publicly said that he was influenced by Ustadji’s singing…Ustadji had a number of disciples, though we may not be aware of many of them…Pt Amarnath, a disciple of Ustad Amir Khan and considered to be a genius of Indore Gharana singing, has chronicled his discipleship and relationship with his guru in great detail…and in recent times, his daughter Bindu Chawla has made every effort to place these chronicles, along with Pt Amarnath’s renditions, before the music world… and in this effort she has received solid support from Underscore Records, a unique record company run by Shubha Mudgal (yeah…the eminent Hindustani classical singer who captured the nation’s imagination through the unusual ‘Ab ke saawan’) and Aneesh Pradhan, the tabla maestro… the first of these reminiscences by Pt Amarnath was in the form of an audio CD called ‘Pioneer of the Khayal – the music of my guru Ustad Amir Khan Saheb’ (Underscore Records)…the CD is in the form of a lec-dem and was recorded live in 1982…here Pt Amarnath speaks about Ustad Amir Khan’s style of khayal singing and sings to demonstrate the unique style…listening to this CD gave me a lot of insights into Ustadji’s singing – the merukhand style, his taans, taranas, and other features…the brief liner notes say… “Called the Bernstein of India, Pt Amarnath … tells you the story of how his legendary guru, Ustad Amir Khan Saheb, not only pioneered a new gharana, but also created a new road to the khayal altogether, changing all earlier perspectives to the form…”
I was listening to Pt Amarnath’s singing for the first time in this CD…I liked it immensely…and I remember writing a mail to Shubhaji asking her if it was possible for Underscore Records to come out with at least a couple of albums of Pt Amarnath’s khayal renderings…Shubhaji wrote back saying that Bindu Chawla held all the rights and that Underscore Records would be happy to produce the albums…this was a long time back…at least 2 years ago… and they did produce 3 albums of hindustani classical vocal by Pt Amarnath sometime last year… the moment I saw them on the website, I wanted to buy them…but as it sometimes happens, it took a long time for me to actually buy them…which was…as recent as 10 days ago…I bought 2 CDs… Pandit Amaranth – Stirrings from the Soul: Vols 1 & 2…there is one more called Seep ke Moti: Pearls from the Oyster, which I intend to buy soon…
But what made me to finally buy these 2 albums was the fact that Underscore Records recently put up a book for sale in their print section which really caught my attention…and I had to own and read this book…Prophets of Indore: Memories of Ustad Amir Khan Saheb by Pandit Amarnathji … this amazing book (I am half way through…) is translated from the Hindustani into English by Bindu Chawla and published by Pandit Amarnath Memorial Foundation …
It is a bilingual book with the page on right in hindustani (devanagari script) and its translation in English on the left… the language is everyday spoken hindustani with all mid sentence pauses and stops and interrogatives…and makes for very interesting reading…as though Pt Amarnath is sitting right in front of you and speaking to you… Pt Amarnath talks about the world of Ustad Amir Khan’s khayal in the 40s-50s-60s…and it is a different world of music...of discussions, soirees, chamber concerts…and significantly, Pt Amarnath’s narration of the recognition of Ustad Amir Khan as a pioneer of a new gharana and style of khayal after Khansaheb’s death by critics and experts…and more than anything else, the emphasis in the Pt Amarnath’s narration on Ustad Amir Khan’s reflection and thinking about khayal & Hindustani classical music which made Khansaheb a great singer and an innovator…
Thank you…Shubhaji and Bindu Chawla for bringing out such gems for the aam aadmi… a forgotten magnificent piece of music history and music is now before us…
I really didn’t think that I’d write so much…but, I think I got carried away…
Jayasrinivasa Rao
Tuesday, March 18, 2008
Reading Namita Devidayal's 'The Music Room'
Early this week, I received two books that I had ordered from Indiaplaza. Actually, I had placed orders for three books…but the third one is out of stock and will take time to reach me… the two books that I received were not entirely new or recently released ones … The Music Room by Namita Devidayal (Random House, India) was released in 2007 to appreciative reviews in all major newspapers and magazines and was recommended by Pt Ravi Shankar as a must read for all musicians and music lovers … I wanted to buy the book as soon as it was released…and it took me almost 5 months to finally get it and read it…I love reading books on Indian classical music, especially the memoir and the socio-politico-cultural kind, and have a quite a good collection of them…I have this great ambition of doing some kind of research on Indian music, any genre…and this reading, I tell myself, will all go into this research…I don’t want to produce a tome or something like that…a couple of articles or research papers will make me happy… this reading has resulted in me buying and reading different kinds of books on Indian classical music…Two Men and Music: Nationalism in the Making of an Indian Classical Tradition by Janaki Bakhle (Permanent Black, ND); Ustad Alladiya Khan’s autobiography My Life (Thema, Calcutta); The Lost World of Hindustani Music (Penguin, India) by Kumar Prasad Mukherji; Pt Mallikarjun Mansur’s autobiography Rasa Yatra: My Journey in Music (Roli Books, New Delhi); Singing the Classical, Voicing the Modern: The Post Colonial Politics of Music in South India by Amanda Weidman (Duke University Press); Between Two Tanpuras (Popular Prakashan) by Vaman H. Deshpande; Indian Musical Traditions: An Aesthetic Study of the Gharanas in Hindustani Music (Popular Prakashan) by Vaman H. Deshpande … and many more…anyway… I enjoyed my encounters with these stalwart writers and gained many insights into this great art form… in more than one instance, the human beings behind the artistes and performers are revealed and we see them in turns as temperamental, egotistical, mischievous, funny, etc., like any one of us…Vaman Deshpande’s Indian Musical Traditions gave me a sound knowledge of the inner workings of the gharana system and his evaluation of Jaipur gharana as a complex amalgamation of the two pillars of Khyal music – swara and laya – got me hooked into taking a slightly deeper interest in the khyal gayaki of the Jaipur gharana … somewhere during this listening and reading, Thema of Calcutta released the autobiography of the founder of Jaipur Gharana, Ustad Alladiya Khan, My Times. In my humble opinion, this is a landmark book for those interested in the growth and development of Hindustani music…and so, when I heard that The Music Room was about the Jaipur gharana, I was intrigued … and I started reading it the day I received and finished it in two days…it is an intensely moving story of one of the unsung stalwarts of Jaipur gharana – Dhondutai Kulkarni. The book is mainly structured as the author’s musical journey, where she weaves in the stories of Dhondutai Kulkarni, her guru the irrepressible Kesarbai Kerkar, and Kesarbai’s guru, the great Ustad Alladiya Khan…and in spite of this impressive lineage and also having learnt music from Ustad Alladiya Khan’s second son Ustad Manji Khan … Dhondutai never becomes the concert star that her guru Kesarbai was famously was…the poignancy and the sense of being sidelined and the pride of belonging to this impressive lineage are all wonderfully narrated by Namita Devidayal, herself now a part of this grand lineage…Namita Devidayal never comes out with reasons for Dhondutai Kulkarni’s destiny as an unrecognised gem of the Jaipur gharana…but enough hints are interspersed throughout the narrative for readers to reach their conclusions…I wish many more readers for this wonderful book…and best wishes to Namita Devidayal on her music career…don’t stop singing…both of you…guru and shishyaa…
Jayasrinivasa Rao

